Ashton_Grewal's Blog

Is Corey Perry the worst Hart Trophy winner ever?

By Ashton_Grewal | View all Posts
Posted Thursday, June 23, 2011 01:01 PM   14 comments
Did you hear the news? Corey Perry won the Hart Trophy – also known as the NHL’s most valuable player award – last night in Vegas.

Never heard of Perry before? You’re not alone. The Anaheim Duck winger had a great season, finishing with the league lead in goals and 98 points.

Hart Trophy winner Corey Perry.Does he deserve recognition for his brilliant play? Absolutely. A nice handshake and a pat on the back ought to do the trick. The Hart Trophy though? Come on, that's absurd.

You wanna know why? Because there’s about 10 other players I’d take on my team before him. I’m serious. If we’re just listing off best players in the league, how many names do we call out before we even think about Corey Perry?

Eight, maybe, nine guys?

I understand there’s a difference between the most valuable player and the most outstanding player. But doesn't it rub anyone else the wrong way that Corey Perry has as many Hart Trophies as Sidney Crosby? Like, isn’t that just effed up?  

Think of it this way. Let's say tomorrow, the NHL decides to throw a party for all the Hart Trophy winners. Wayne Gretzky is shooting the shit with Bobby Orr next to a grand piano, Mario Lemieux is at the bar trying to convince former teammate Jaromir Jagr to rejoin the Penguins, Mark Messier is at the coat check explaining to Eric Lindros how to skate with your head up and Gordie Howe is on the patio having a smoke and telling Peter Forsberg about the his first career hat trick.

And then, Corey Perry walks in with Henrik Sedin and Jose Theodore. The room goes silent.

And why wouldn’t it? You think any of the all-time greats can relate to these schmucks? Do you really think Phil Esposito and Bobby Clarke would let Perry rub elbows with them?

Okay this blog post just hit double digits for rhetoric questions. I’ve got to slow down. I’m just worked up that’s all.

And I’m not really a big hockey fan. I just think this is a joke and needs to be discussed. The voters need to look beyond the top three scorers as the sole candidates for the Hart Trophy. Zdeno Chara anyone?
14 comments
comment Post A Comment
doliver517 says:
06/23/11 01:31PM
I'm definatly not a big hockey fan although I do live in Hockeytown. I only watch Hockey if I'm forced to during the regular season but watch every game in the playoffs. However, when reading the bottom line on ESPN i had to hit rewind when they showed who the mvp was. I've never heard of the guy, never. A nameless MVP in my opinion is not good for the sport and quite frankly gives me no reason to tune into a mid December game because a pretty good Anaheim Duck is playing. And why is hockey being played in Anaheim California anyway. The whole sport is ass backwards. I wouldn't mind if they just went back to the original six and that was it.
LeRinkRat says:
06/23/11 03:31PM

not as embarrassing as Daniel Sedin winning the Ted Lindsay. WHAT where his fellow NHL players THINKING? I can think of half a dozen players more valueable to their team with Tim Thomas at the top and including Corry Perry.

and as for Perry, living in Las Vegas I watch a lot of Ducks games and Perry is the real deal. at 26 he's just peaking and playing with Bobby Ryan and Ryan Getzlaf on the "RPG Line", he should continue to fill the net. that line is one reason I think that the Ducks are the best long shot to come out of the West next season IF they upgrade their goaltending.

Weekends says:
06/23/11 03:54PM

Jose Theodore aside, I think you could probably make that argument. I don't think it's all that bad though, Martin St.Louis had a pretty similar career trajectory as Perry going into his Hart trophy year and he's going to end up with some pretty good numbers when he retires.  

It's hard to argue against Perry this season though. 50 goals, 11 game winners, and he single-handedly carried his mediocre team while Getzlaf was injured.

claude_gir0ux says:
06/23/11 04:36PM
no...
Damix says:
06/23/11 05:01PM

Sedins are very professional and courteous.
They dont deserve the hate they all get for just the way they look.
People are racist towards the sedins in my opinion.
OnlyGod says:
06/23/11 05:09PM


Sweet was he nice ? 
beedahosen says:
06/23/11 06:33PM
perry had an awesome year,,, he deserved the hart............also , have you followed anything this kid has done in his career?......hes won absolutely everything at every level.....plus hes from my hometown
Niners13 says:
06/23/11 06:36PM
he deserved it.


JeffSymons says:
06/25/11 02:37PM
It's quite obvious you don't know anything about hockey....but there is no need to embarrass yourself any further...if you know so little about Corey Perry, I suggest you report on things that don't make you sound like a total Jack Ass....
DDH420 says:
06/26/11 12:21AM
Little harsh there JerkSymptoms,especially for a Lions fan that rides balloon tires on his Camaro so he can drive on gravel roads and rub his ground effects into concrete parking dividers. And congrats to Katie Perry but he is arguably the best player on his team (I'd take Getz any day to start my team) let alone the best in the league.
FORTUNATESON says:
06/26/11 01:59PM
I respectfully disagree. Perry played all 82 games for the second season in a row, and kept the ducks in a playoff spot while some of his team-mates were injured. He finished with the most goals in the league, and was 3rd in points.
JeffSymons says:
06/26/11 05:12PM
Well said, "Fortunateson'...playing all 82 games in this era is a feat in itself, especially when Perry never takes a shift off, and even plays the role of enforcer....in the stretch run, he went on an incredible, and unbelievabe scoring spree to carry the Ducks into the playoffs...
vijli says:
10/28/11 04:58PM
This article is so bad, you should never wright about hockey again. It is like you want to piss off hockey fans. Disgusting .....
tidostyles says:
12/15/11 03:23AM
Corey Perry fights, scores, kills penalties. He's a Stanley Cup and Memorial Cup champion. He's a tough Canadian boy. Getzlaf was out for a huge part of the season and Perry carried the Ducks on his back. Say what you want, but I think he deserves more than a pat on the back!
Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 
Advertisement