FreedomAtStake's Blog

Missing a $50 billion opportunity

By FreedomAtStake | View all Posts
Posted Friday, February 27, 2009 10:59 AM   13 comments
Fifty billion dollars.

That's what America is leaving on the table by not legalizing, regulating, and taxing online gambling right now.

Fifty billion dollars.

According to a report by PriceWaterhouseCoopers (PWC), America could raise over $50 billion by repealing the UIGEA and taking online gambling.

Fifty billion dollars.

Now, y'all might remember that last year I wrote about a similar report by PWC that stated potential online revenues of only $42 billion.

So, what changed in the meantime?

Nothing. In fact, that is the most startling part of this report.

Last year's analysis factored in the likely effects of the UIGEA and its then-probable dampening effect on the online gambling industry.

This year's analysis realized that the UIGEA, in fact, has done very little to stop the growth of the online gambling industry, and therefore PWC increased the upper limit of the industry's potential by another 20%, given that the industry obviously is stronger than they originally expected.

So there you go.

As this report underscores, the UIGEA represents the worst kind of legislation.

Regardless of where you stand on people's personal rights to spend their money where they want, you still have to marvel at the UIGEA's ability to injure the online gambling industry even while it is failing to stop the activity from increasing.

A true paradox.

This all shows a remarkable similarity to other failed forms of prohibition, from alcohol to drugs. The more the government tries to stop people from vices, the more they just drive the activity underground, where it can not be taxed and regulated.

Even the usually-conservative free market think tank, the Competitive Enterprise Institute published an article this week touting the positives of online gambling.

Congratulations are in order for Bill Frist, Jon Kyl, and the rest of the evangelical Republican right-wing social conservatives. By forcing the UIGEA down the throats of Americans, they succeeded in creating another billion dollar black-market industry.

Nice work, guys. America couldn't use the billions of potential dollars right now, could it?

Luckily, we are seeing a bit of a governmental thaw towards these unrealistic policies now that Obama has taken power.

Not only is this administration immediately taking a much softer line against marijuana, but hopefully we will see Barney Frank re-launch his bill to repeal the UIGEA.

My only question is: Is this bill by Barney Frank even necessary?

Wouldn't it be much quicker and easier to simply use the Congressional Review Act to stop the UIGEA from going into enforcement? My contacts tell me that the CRE definitely applies in this case, but for some reason the Dems seem reluctant to use it.

It's not too late and, uh, the economy could kinda use that money ASAP.

13 comments
comment Post A Comment
pjrez says:
02/27/09 03:47PM
rally107 says:
02/28/09 01:03AM
will the government get the idea???
MRSARATOGA says:
02/28/09 08:27AM
I am probably the only one who doesn't want America taking online gaming.  The threat and certainly actual occurrences of fixing and pressure on teams to cover spreads when the game itself is basically over would ruin things as the poeple that lose (which would be most people) would create an albatross around sports that does not exist now in the U.S.  
betlarge says:
02/28/09 08:26PM
The CRE can be used and would be a more effective campaign in my opinion...
kerryvonerick says:
03/01/09 07:32PM
Fathomable says:
03/02/09 06:34AM
    always enjoy your write ups freedom. lets hope this dosent take too long.
WiLdCaRd88 says:
03/02/09 02:53PM
OBAMA ISNT STUPID...wouldn't be surprised if marijuana and online gambling were legal within the next 4 years...

bluejays99 says:
03/02/09 02:59PM
I work at pwc... I should get on this... hahaha
steinmans80 says:
03/05/09 03:10PM
When is Frank going to try again?
iceman52 says:
03/05/09 03:54PM
I thionk we are better off without our government getting invoved in anything that runs smooth it is best just like it is. If queen nacy or gober franks invoved the juice will double and the games will be fixed. Sometimes when things run smooth it is best to leave and let run. I have been gaming on the net for at least 6 yrs and never had any problems and I could care less if it is legal or not. I still believe in freedom if what I do doesnt hurt someone else I will do it regardless of the decision of our wonderful government what a bunch of clowns we have in charge..
FreedomAtStake says:
03/05/09 04:37PM
iceman, saratoga...

The problem is that while things might be running smoothly for you, they sure ain't going smooth for the majority of users.

Sportsbooks still only manage to sign up a small percentage of people who actually want to play, mainly because of the restrictions on credit cards.

As for the possibility of cheating, well, it really hasn't been a big problem in Europe, has it? Sure, there's been a few minor scandals, but the fact is that when players are getting paid millions, it becomes next to impossible to get them to throw a game.

Philly215 says:
03/05/09 08:38PM
The question I ask is, how do you regulate it? It would cost Billions of dollars to do so. And what would stop American companies and bettors from continuing to play at offshore sites, where there would remain no tax liability for either. I am in favor of repealing the UIGEA, as I feel that too many of these offshore sites are "fixed". I would rather see some regulation, that way I knew I was getting a fair shot, even if that meant a tax liability and probably less promotion offers and bonuses from the books.

Smokin weed and playin online poker, Americas new pastime!!!

LeRinkRat says:
03/07/09 07:51PM
the other consideration that could sell this is that when states legalized the lottery, it effectively busted the illegal "numbers" and "policy" games. same with OTB esp in NY City. that put the illegal horse race books out of business?

ending the sports betting prohibition would affectively do the same thing.

and as for "It would cost Billions of dollars to do so", how about the amount of money that would be saved on law inforcement NOT chasing around illegal sportsbook operations?

millions OR even billions in federal and state revenues AND God knows how many American jobs created just seems like common sense esp with the current stae of the economy.

Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 
Advertisement