J_Logan's Blog

UFC screw job

By J_Logan | View all Posts
Posted Sunday, October 25, 2009 01:16 AM   15 comments
UFC 104 was a night of surprises for me.

For one, I actually did well with my picks going 4-for-5 after feeling like a Madden curse for MMA fighters the last couple events.

Second, Maurico Rua surprised me with the way he controlled the pace of the bout and had Lyoto Machida on the defense all night.

But the biggest surprise came when ring announcer Bruce Buffer announced Machida was the winner by unanimous decision after taking a beating for five rounds. Sure, I'm happy I cashed my ticket and that my column on Machida winning the light heavyweight title fight wasn't thrown in my face.

But Shogun Rua was screwed.

I know it. You know it. Rua knows it. Even Machida knows it.

Joe Rogan nearly bit through his tongue he was holding it so hard in the post-fight interviews. The judges did such a bad job of scoring the fight – if they really did score it – they make Golden Boy Promotions panel look good. Fight fans haven't seen a screw job this raw since Vince McMahon pulled the plug on Brett Hart back in '97. The fight was fake but the outcome was very, very real.

It makes you think that maybe Dana White and his big-money buddies had some heavy action on "The Dragon" at -500. The claws of Las Vegas can stretch as far as Los Angeles.

But whether Saturday night's decision was an honest mistake or call made from up on top, this controversial finish would hopefully spawn a rematch. However, with the UFC's recent push for superbouts and a guy like Anderson Silva calling the shots, MMA fans are more likely to see Silva-Rua than Machida-Rua 2. Rua may never get another shot at the 205-pound title - which should be his after handling one of the sports' top fighters.

Sorry, Shogun. In a sport as primitive and natural as MMA, politics have reared their ugly head. Mixed martial arts has battled hard to become a “real” sport in the eyes of doubters. And just like other “real” sports, sometimes the outcome of the game doesn't always happen on the field – or this case the cage. Sometimes the final decision comes from a front office desk or a ring-side seat.
15 comments
comment Post A Comment
Johnboy85 says:
10/25/09 01:31AM
Well, I called Shogun in your article.  Everyone was writing him off.  This guy is for real, and should be LHW champ.  This is the worst decision I've seen by far.
Buckeye85 says:
10/25/09 01:50AM
I agree that to be the champ you have to beat the champ.  And no round was completely dominated by either of them.  But I still only give 1 round (maybe 2, but that is a BIG maybe) to Machida.  So winning 4 rounds is pretty dominate to me.  Not to mention, when they announced that it was a unanimous decision I thought that it was obviously going to be in favor of Shogun.  There is no way that all three of them really thought that Machida won that fight, that is just ridiculous.  I really just think this shows how bad some of these judges are to be honest.  And yes, I was on Shogun, and Michigan St to add to the pain.  Felt like I got robbed out of $ on both.
J_Logan says:
10/25/09 01:55AM
I'm an associate editor for Covers.com and cover pretty much everything you can bet on including MMA.
willowtip says:
10/25/09 03:10AM
immediate rematch already pretty much confirmed by dana white in post fight press conference. really tough fight to score, those rounds were really tight.
Stinky1 says:
10/25/09 04:41AM
I grew up watching King Rex.

What is your association with Chapman and the Cats?

I see Canadian under your tag.


J_Logan says:
10/25/09 10:23AM
Rex Chapman was one of my favorite players growing up. He could do it all. Rex-NFX for life!
Pimparoo says:
10/25/09 01:25PM
Do the judges submit their scores after every round because if you go by a 10 point scoring system its hard to give the win to machida all that garbage about you have to beat the champ business is garbage because we've seen titles change hands without a knockout. That is some serious BS its looking like boxing in the old days again. Machida rushes Rua and everybody thinks that he's going for the kill...come on he never committed on any of his punches because his ribs were getting punished. The tactician was outsmarted last night and there should be a new champ, I can't believe 2 judges gave machida rounds 1-3 ridiculous why don't you just say that you took a bribe because a loved one was being held captive. This was one of the worst decisions in awhile for combat sports i thought I was in the twilight zone and Don King was going to jump out.
jk-time says:
10/25/09 01:33PM
After all the BS with Boxing.......I left it.....rarely do I watch a Boxing match anymore. I really hope that this is not the beginnning of things to come in the UFC. I am interested in finding out exactly what Dana White said to Shogun immediately after the decision was announced, And Shogun didn't seem too hurt by the whole deal. Makes one wonder. Now that UFC fights are all over Vegas it brings into question, as in Boxing, as to the legitimacy of the sport. This is the first time I have seen such a flagrant screw-up.... SAD to see.... Is Dana White becoming......Dana King..... Let's hope not !
GolliAA1 says:
10/25/09 02:40PM
I do believe there will be a rematch between these two, but I don't think it will be an immediate rematch. The division has too many contenders to tie up another 6 months on Machida/Rua. Most likely, both will fight at least one more time before they meet again.
Stinky1 says:
10/25/09 03:03PM
I guess that will remain a mystery.

Go Cats.

Let John Wall play NCAA bitches.


steelersrule says:
10/25/09 07:42PM
reading dana whites lips he said to rua "i had you winning the fight" right after the match in the ring after the decision was announced
ATX_HornsWin says:
10/25/09 10:00PM
J Logan, you are absolutely right! I personally banned all boxing matches becuase this same kind of BS kept happening. The calls followed the big money. I'm a huge fan of MMA and the thing I liked best is there was little political influence. This was horrible. At a minimum they should have call a split decision to not make it look so obvious! If this keeps up my UFC PPV purchases will come to an end. The betting line was so big, that there was no way a decesion could go Rua's way. Horrible night for the UFC in my opinion
mikeshelton31 says:
10/25/09 10:26PM
Well you should take homo-sex off as your avitar. I went to high school with him. Total tool but had hot sister.
KTAKILLA says:
10/26/09 02:33AM
now days its all about the money!!! many fights i feel was set up! Rua should have won the match!
quicksandAA says:
10/26/09 02:58AM
It was a sad day for UFC Fans,, I loved pride and and shogun is a great fighter.. When i seen he was a 4-1 dog i put 200 on him even though the dragon is my fav fighter. I watched the fight and I thought shogun's gameplan was perfect agaist his style and i thought shogun won every round. After the fight i was so happy i had won 800 dollars and was very proud of my pick. I mean the dragon was paying like no value. Anyways After the said the Dragon won I felt like pukeing because I knew that alot of people who bet put money on the underdawg because of the great value. UFC is now a joke in my eyes, Dana |White is the new DON KING.. How am i ever going to bet again I cant trust the fucken judges!

Now why would Fador come to the UFC after a joke like that! Its insane im so pissed off.. I think they should reverse the decision. Rematch is a joke but im sure shogun won't leave it up to the judges..

Quicksand

Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 
Advertisement