J_Logan's Blog

Does the punishment fit the crime?

By J_Logan | View all Posts
Posted Saturday, September 05, 2009 12:53 AM   21 comments
Not since Kermit Washington broke Rudy Tomjanovich's face has a punch made such waves in the sports world (besides boxing, MMA and Woody Hayes).

Oregon senior running back LeGarrette Blount has been suspended for the season after giving Boise State DE Byron Hout "a rap on the Jack Johnson" following the Ducks' opening loss to the Broncos Thursday night.

In Blount's defense, the bad blood has been boiling between these teams since last year and Hout's postgame trash talk deserved to be checked.

That said, did Blount's punishment fit the crime?

It was a cheap shot – no doubt – but the entire year?

A player can beat up a girl at a campus party, get arrested by the police and still make practice the next day. These crimes, which outweigh smacking some doucher upside the head, go unpunished most of the time because they happen off the field and outside of the public eye.

But when Blount landed a snap right hand square on the Hout's glass jaw (he went down like a sack of potatoes), it was in front of a national audience – not to mention Pac-10 commissioner Larry Scott, who was in attendance Thursday. Besides giving Hout's jaw that annoying clicking sound, the punch was a black eye on the NCAA's recent push on sportsmanship.

My favorite scene from the postgame melee was the when Blount was leaving the field in front of a crowd of BSU faithful.

There is an older gentleman in a white polo who channels the spirit of 2PAC, points at Blount while mouthing the weapon of choice of classic college football hecklers everywhere.

That guy's wife must be so proud – and so is his high school chemistry class. I wonder if he'll get an unfair suspension too?

Anyways, back to the argument: Should Blount be suspended for the entire year?
21 comments
comment Post A Comment
ksuwins says:
09/05/09 12:59AM
Let's see...punched a dude in the face,  punched his own teammate, went after the fans, and gave the cops a hard time.  I don't know...I guess I could see him starting next week against Purdue as long as he was forced to sit next to coach all the way home.
vegasdennis says:
09/05/09 01:01AM



Vegasbuster says:
09/05/09 01:01AM
I would have sat him for half the year.

Which was worse: Haynesworth intentionally stepping on Gurode's face in 2006 or Blount throwing a retaliatory punch at Hout for something he obviously said which pissed off Blount? Haynesworth was only suspended for 5 games, but he was mere inches away from blinding Gurode.
chino1922 says:
09/05/09 01:16AM
This is College football not a night in the hood! If this attitude is not checked hard it could spread like wild fire through the NCAA!

Going after the fans and attacking like a madman put the icing on the cake! I think he should of shoved the dude who tapped him on the shoulder and taunted him instead of what he did!  Yes......the punishment fits the crime!!!!

CalBear says:
09/05/09 01:19AM
I wouldn't be surprised if Oregon rescinded the suspension and he comes back later in the year...IF he shows good behavior.
Godfather16 says:
09/05/09 01:46AM
a few games, the whole year is simply unfair, and the Boise player was showing no class heckling and goading Blount.
jebe99 says:
09/05/09 01:51AM
I would say the punishment wasn't enough.

Lock the f**ker up for assault.

I'm tired of watching these so called athletes acting like f**king gangbangers on national TV.


Dsr_9 says:
09/05/09 09:35AM
Jebe brings up a good point. He could have been charged with assualt for that if they really wanted to go after him.

If the NCAA is truly wanting to clean this up and are going to enforce this from here on out, then yes...the punishment is just. If they are going to go soft and lighten the action, it will just show everyone that this is just another "empty policy" set forth by the NCAA.

It's a shame he has to be made an example, but in the long run this will deter other unfortunate behavior within the sport...hopefully.

20658 says:
09/05/09 10:51AM
Yes, Blount should get whatever he put himself at risk of receiving. However, that Boise State Player should also get some sort of disciplinary action. If not for what he started none of this is happening.

We all get told to do your talking on the football field, and that's what Boise State did. Blount was walking off with his head down dejected....exactly what a trash talker deserves, and then #94 taps, pushes, touches...whatever you wanna call it but he makes sure that he has Blount's attention because he wants to be unsportsmanlike for just another moment. The classic shot to the jaw and drops him to the ground. The Boise State player pretty much yelled fire in a crowded building. But that does not excuse Blount's reaction and actions after the fact.

mightiestmojo says:
09/05/09 11:45AM
Laughing my ass off. That boise guy fell like a dead man. Great shot. Obviously the NCAA needs to put Blount out for that but maybe the guy can get into boxing or something.
Art_Van_De_Lay says:
09/05/09 02:44PM
If Blount's punch had missed, what would the punishment have been?
KittyKatz286 says:
09/05/09 02:54PM
The punishment does not fit the crime. This guy should've been thrown out of the school. He should thank the NCAA for allowing him to stay in college at all. Are you kidding me? There is nothing worse than a violent act that is completely unnecessary. There is absolutely no possible explanation for why Blount punched that guy in the face. Therefore, at the very least, his college football career should be done.
BobSeger says:
09/05/09 09:21PM
Reminded me of good ol fashion

hockey in the 70's and 80's. Fans

fighting, players fighting. No one ever

lost their job for a year. Too harsh.

luckylion says:
09/06/09 12:28PM
this is college football. its a privelidge to be able to play and represent your college. no college should accept what he did. so if he is a pro and a fan on the sidewalk taunts him its ok to do that again. we all have to learn lessons ya can't snap when ya want its just a game.
nc1capper says:
09/06/09 03:15PM
my thought is was it was about right with the post game tirade and everything - or near melee after the fact - dude lost his mind for sure, what a nite for the program tho, stunk it up real bad on the field,,AD calling out the coaching staff at the half and the love tap afterwards to put the icing on the cherry - yikes
pchilds says:
09/06/09 04:33PM
I was pleasantly surprised by the season suspension. I believe the punishment is fair because Blount showed absolutely zero self control nor restraint. It's one thing to sucker punch a guy that's not looking, but his behavior after the fact was completely out of control. Who's to say he won't go off again. Then how embarrassed would the University by? The easiest and best way to put this very ugly situation behind them was to suspend him for the year. If they suspended him for 6 games, then 6 weeks from now the team and fans would have to relive the incident again.
Kelly_Slater says:
09/07/09 01:33AM
Its obvious he got a reseonable punishment.

Think about it... his own institution (Oregon) who has the most invested with the MOST to loose STILL decided to suspend him.

Keep in mind the punch represents the University.

Youc cant excuse the behavior its way to fucked.

He should have spit in his face - and got a few games - the dude would have been more insulted!! ---

Just sayin

focheezay says:
09/07/09 08:30PM
Actually Hout could have gotten assult charges filed on him for initiated the situation and O yeah he put his hands on Blount first. However, Blount put his hand(s) on him last, dude dropped like 1$ bills at a strip club LMAO...

Here is a clue if you for the future... If you put hands on someone and run your mouth... People have a tendency to put their hands back on you... At least in the real world thats how people I know handle it...

Good job Blount!

savko08 says:
09/08/09 10:12AM
Blount's a punk, he cried when Coach told him he was suspended for the year, tough guy? Whahhh!!!! Go cry in your Maypo, you PUNK!!!! NCAA did absolutrely the right thing here,they should make him go to anger MNGMT classes too!!! Blount's a PUNK!!!!Whahhhh!!!Cry Baby!!!!
Joker25 says:
09/07/09 07:50AM
Another Lawerence Phillips in the making
Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 
Advertisement