Josh_Nagel's Blog

Discrimination was at the core of the Bartman saga

By Josh_Nagel | View all Posts
Posted Wednesday, September 28, 2011 07:48 PM   20 comments

After watching ESPN’s documentary on the Steve Bartman saga, I was left feeling worse about the human condition of many Chicago Cubs fans more than I felt sorry for Bartman.

At least Bartman left the ordeal with some dignity intact.

The same can’t be said for the hordes of downtrodden Cubs devotees who still blame Bartman for their team’s fate in the 2003 playoff series against the Florida Marlins.

“Catching Hell” was an intriguing addition to the network’s mostly entertaining “30 for 30” film series. The documentary about Bartman’s train wreck with fate as he attempted to snag a pop-up that Cubs outfielder Moises Alou might have had a chance to catch gave viewers some uncomfortable reminders about the ugly side of human nature.

What struck me as most disturbing was not only how so many people associated with the game – including Alou himself – are still shameless and unapologetic for using Bartman as their unofficial punching bag, but the core motivator behind the depths of their venom.

It’s the purest form of discrimination. Bartman’s biggest sin isn’t that reached over and tried to catch the same baseball the Cubs outfielder was trying to track down. He has been crucified because he’s the prototypical target for bullying; he appears shy, reclusive, nerdy and awkward. Like many of us, I can relate.

There’s little doubt anyone in Bartman’s shoes would have been the subject of the fans’ ire, but let’s face it: Had Bartman been passable for Brad Pitt’s twin brother and had what the media considered a winning personality, he would have been invited to be the third man in the booth during the World Series alongside Joe Buck and Tim McCarver.

Had Bartman been an attractive female, she would have been offered to millions to pose in Playboy and had non-stop offers on the talk-show circuit and for movies.

Had Bartman publicly told Cubs fans to buzz off, or vowed to exercise his right to bear arms should one of the haters visit his residence, they might have left him alone sooner.

But instead, we got a deer-in-the-headlights dweeb who escaped from public view more quietly than he entered it. In pop culture, there’s nothing worse than being boring or unattractive, and for this Bartman was never forgiven.

Another bizarre aspect were some of the sources of the “Basically, it’s his own fault” sentiment. One media member labeled Bartman as “meek,” while another observed he “lacked charisma.” There are perhaps no worse candidates for this type of judgment than the double-trip-to-the-free-buffet line, personal-agenda driven majority who populate the mainstream media.

Alou was a disappointment, too. Not only did fail to offer an apology for screaming at Bartman when it happened, he showed no trace of empathy or sympathy for the Cubs fan. He said his biggest regret was that part of his own career’s legacy was tied to that particular play.

I’m of the camp that believes Alou probably wouldn’t have caught it, anyway. I’m also of the belief that it doesn’t matter. Even if you change that one event, it doesn’t mean the course of history would have changed. Nor does it guarantee the same outcome. We’ll just never know.

I think the gripe would have been slightly more justified had Bartman done something that unquestionably influenced the game. For instance, say the Cubs trailed by one run and had runners on first and second. Had he scooped up a fair ball down the left-field line, and perhaps prevented a speedy runner from scoring from first because of the ground-rule double, then at least he could be rightly accused of failing to respect the game.

Even so, this a moot point, because I’ve long suspected the Bartman saga was less about baseball and more about society’s insatiable appetite for feeding frenzies on the perceived weak.

Ironically, though, Bartman has shown he might stronger than all of his critics combined. You have to respect that, despite countless opportunities and the lure of six-figure paydays, he has kept his mouth and his wallet shut at every turn and has been an epic role model for showing others how to get on with their lives past adversity.

But I wouldn’t blame him for changing his mind. He’s already held out for a nearly a decade; I say, hang out another 10 years or so and see if the Cubs ever make the playoffs again. If they do, that’s when he heads straight to the presses with a book titled something like “Foul Play” and hits the talk-show circuit right before Chicago plays its first home game in the series. 

This might give some Cubs fans and media a needed lesson in karma. But the team surely would find its own special way to blow the series.

20 comments
comment Post A Comment
Josh_Nagel says:
09/29/11 04:34PM
DP,

Thanks for the love. Did you see the ESPN movie? It's definitely worthwhile, but also sort of disturbing and tragic in some ways. I recommend it if you get a chance. Peace.

FoolishTool says:
09/29/11 05:47PM
Nice article, yet another reminder of how really fked up the human race is! And no doubt if it had been a hot slutty looking chick instead of Bartman she would have gotton a walk and become filthy rich! Poor Bartman, his life ruined all because of basically a meaningless baseball game, so what if the cubs would have won, big fkn deal, it would'nt have solved any of the world's many major problems! ,,,,,,,, maybe if you had huge money on the game then you can bitch a little but i'm sure 99% of the bitchers had nothing riding on the game except their ego! ,,,,,,,, sports is good entertainment to the masses and money to the owners and players and thats the bottom line!
Mike41082 says:
09/29/11 06:13PM
Bartman could have made some money off of it, he choose not to... I commend him for that... Alou was the main cause of it. His reaction is what fueld it all and it was highly unprofessional, if he would have just walked away and not singled the guy out (which was only one of like 3 people that went 4 the ball), it wouldnt have got as much attention.. Im suprised Bartman didnt try 2 sue Alou, the Cubs, Fox using that argument, but again; Thats a testement to his seemingly good nature...I didnt see the espn show, I liked your article... but, you cant defend the guy for looking the way he does, pointing out how shitty most people in society are for being the way they are... and at the same time implying those types of people are fat and using that as a derogatory put down.
MaineRoad says:
09/29/11 06:40PM
A disgusting example of white-on-white crime.
Josh_Nagel says:
09/29/11 07:13PM
Mike41082,

Just to clarify: My point about the media members, whom I've been around for the better part of two decades, was not to make fun of their weight (unlike the movie "Shallow Hal," the premise of which is "Beauty is skin deep," but is actually 2 hours of fat jokes).

My point is that most of them are freeloaders who never met a handout they didn't like (including the free media buffet at most sporting events), are afraid to write or say anything negative about the coach or athlete they worship for fear of being eliminated as a candidate to write the guy's biography and, in this day and age, most are willing to do almost anything to draw the attention of ESPN or CNN and become part of the story themselves.

I was trying to say these people, with this sort of widespread mentality, are in no posiiton to judge Steve Bartman's level of charisma. Thanks for reading.

SashimiKid says:
09/29/11 10:33PM
My perception of the Cubs' organization and fans will forever be tainted after watching this show. What disgusting behavior by Cubs fans and also to the Chicago media for announcing his address on television knowing he had received death threats. But what do you expect from fans who continue to support this loser organization year after year, I'm sure the owners laugh all the way to the bank knowing these dumb shits will empty their wallets supporting another 74-88 team.
faceoff says:
09/30/11 10:41AM
I have to digest this article for a few minutes, because; although it is from a different perspective and well written, it is full of holes................................ First off, If bartman was fat and hairy, but had a gregarious personality, he would have been on every t.v. program in the country........ Including the Late Show and all talk shows..................... Cub fans are no different than any other fans in any other country...................... Look around at the animals as they find excuses for mayhem and destruction...................

Seriously think about it over the past 20 years or more............... Cub fans are just like all emotionally laden fans throughout the world..................................................... Bartman chose not to appear anywhere......... The kid probably LOVED HIS CUBS until that moment of unconscious reaction..................................................... bartman withdrew into himself as a survival tactic.... Involintarily fight or flight... That was his flight aspect to try and become invisible........................ A media guy was there at his side handing out a card within 5 minutes of the incident.................................. Nice try Josh.... Good article..... But disingenuous to say the least................

Joker25 says:
09/30/11 04:05PM
Mike Golic said if Bartman was 6'5 280 lbs would have that guy dumped a beer on him???
Josh_Nagel says:
09/30/11 04:57PM
Faceoff,

I respect your right to disagree, but I would say "disingenous" is an inaccurate depiction of my commentary. You're right, Bartman chose flight over fight when it came to the heat he was receiving. My point is, "a fight-or-flight" decision was one he should have never had to make. It's not like he got drunk and hit someone with his car, then fled the scene. He didn't commit a crime or even do anything wrong, per se.

I saw a good portion of the replay of "Catching Hell" last night. One thing that caught my attention that I didn't see before is that it appears the guy in the white sweater in front of Bartman makes a much more aggressive play for the ball than Bartman himself. But Alou and everyone else found Bartman to be a more viable scapegoat.

Take care.

faceoff says:
09/30/11 05:16PM
Looks like the ball actually hit the ''guy in the white sweaters '' forearm when he reached out for it...................... You should write a piece for T.V. on the excitement (made for t.v. documentary) of the '' final day of baseball 2011......... Depicting how the playoffs were basically decided on that final day............... You are a good writer, I didn't mean anything bad by what I said..................... I actually thought you were going to say it was because he was Jewish............ How dumb is that....? ........ What could have happened as opposed to what did happen........ Sort of like turning left instead of turning right at the junction..................................
vacation says:
10/01/11 05:23PM
While the treatment of Bartman well after the incident was cruel and over the top, Bartman has no one to blame but himself. He interfered with the game at a crucial moment. That ball was clearly catchable. Bartman acted selfishly. Now, one could attempt to excuse Bartman for doing something stupid for perhaps the only time in his life. In my work you do not get to act with stupidity when that act is deliberate and be excused.

If you want a ball that badly, go buy one. They are $7.50 each.

wolves967 says:
10/01/11 09:59PM
Bartman was the best thing that happened to Alex Gonzalez! Everyone never talks about that reality.
dyamarik says:
10/02/11 08:49AM
wolves967 is right. Gonzales would be have been the scapegoat had the Bartman foul been three feet farther foul.

Great read - I watched the doucmentary and was sickened at the state of human nature, and especially of Alou. My kids are always looking up to baseball and football players as role models, and I constatnly tell them to look up to their parents, school principal, teachers, or the police officers or fireman that dedicate their lives to helping the world be a better place. The last place to try and find a role model is these overpaid, egocentric jack-asses that are blessed to play playground games for millions of dollars.

Alou is the perfect example of just how self-centered and egotistical most all atheletes are. He was clearly thinking of the incident as "how did it affect me" than anything else. He sure moved up the "biggest D-Bag in the world" list in my eyes.

I give Bartman kudos for be as courageous as he has been. A lot of weaker people would have sold-out, or be permanently damaged (mentally) by such nastiness.

Peace.

ShereensPicks says:
10/02/11 09:06AM
While Bartman, IMO didn't deserve the all-out ire he received, I do think that our society is also trying to hard to be a kinder, more gentle 'don't call people on their mistakes....'

Bottom line: He messed up the play, it WAS a huge play, I'm pretty sure Alou makes the catch easily.

It does show how sad Cubs fans are to lean so heavily on it, but the guy was an idiot for what he did, everyone knows you let your team catch any ball they can.

misterwonderful says:
10/02/11 07:58PM
PURE AND SIMPLE, GOOD READ!!!
misterwonderful says:
10/02/11 07:59PM
PURE AND SIMPLE, GOOD READ!!!
fla says:
10/04/11 08:50AM
if gonzo turns the double play all's good
lalooter says:
12/20/11 10:44PM
a liittle late, but damm iam glad i read it.
swag300 says:
01/06/12 10:46AM
Swaggy sez...............Bartman is a REAL human being..Cub fans , not even close..Alou was an overrated player anyway and the rest of the family that played the game were too. There would of been NO WAY for me to have maintained a cool head through out the entire ordeal like Bartman did...Id STILL have lawsuits brewing on the calendar to this day and Id be hunting down the fans that threatened me with todays technologies and private detectives...You have to be narrowminded to think that ONE play turned the game and series around and turned the Cubs into a cursed team to this day...Theyre bad , they were bad then and they will be forever bad..Hey Bartman , your alright in my book..Hey Chicago fans , kiss my arse!
braves5795 says:
01/27/12 04:09PM
bartman certainly wasn't the 1st idiot to interfere by trying to get a ball and will not be the last, fucking fans are idiots most of the time at any sporting event. Why does a 40 year old man want to paint himself up anyway.
Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 
Advertisement