Michaelperry's Blog

Need to Get Rid Of Penalty Kicks for Big Games

By Michaelperry | View all Posts
Posted Friday, November 27, 2009 09:56 AM   2 comments
Real Salt Lake won this year's MLS Cup over heavily favored Los Angeles and while the result was surprising, it didnt surprise me that much that this game ended up with penalty kicks deciding the winner. It seems as if any big soccer result ends up coming down to penalty kicks. Soccer needs to change their rules on this. Not asking for big radical moves here, just ones in regards to high profile matches, such as the World Cup.

The past two World Cups have been decided by penalty kicks, and in my opinion, I think that somewhat tarnishes the result. I know the soccer purists out there are against changing the rules, but what is wrong with having the game decided by the same way in which you played it for the past 90+ minutes. Yes, I realize that players get tired after running up and down the pitch so much during this contests, but endurance is part of the game.

Here is my proposal. Have a 45 minute sudden death period (with a 15 minute break after each sudden death period), where each team has three opportunites to subsitute players. If they prefer, teams can also make substitutions for players who previously left game.

What makes a product good is consistency, and thats why soccer should change to this format in order to make the world's most popular sport even that much more popular.

2 comments
comment Post A Comment
vanzack says:
11/27/09 10:52AM
Couldnt agree more.

There are lots of good ideas - yours is one - in addition:

After the 30 minute OT - start removing one player on each side every 5 minutes until someone scores.

After the 30 minute OT - Remove the goalkeepers ability to use his hands...

Inglewood_Jack says:
11/27/09 12:52PM
While penalty shots are great for the spectators, I agree 100% with michaelperry. It does not make sense to decide games on penalty kicks or even penalty shots like in hockey. We lose focus on it being a team sport.

It comes down to two individuals deciding the game for two teams and it is nonsensical.

Why not just flip a coin.

Love Vanzack's idea of removing a player every 5 minutes but for flow of game, how about removing 3-4 players every 5-10 minutes? every 5 would create too many stoppages maybe.

Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 
Advertisement