In the case of Peyton Manning vs Eli Manning the question is who is the better MAN-NING! At first glance the answer would be Peyton right? In 12 seasons he's considered one of the all-time greats. He's won 3 regular season MVP's and  a Super Bowl MVP, he's thrown for 336 TD's, his 64.5 complection pct. is 3rd all-time (among QB's with 1500 attempts). He's the Colts all-time winningest QB (but doesn't like to be compared to Johnny "U") He's the master of the 2 min drill and has led countless 4th qtr combacks including Monday night against Miami. He's started 178 straight games second all-time only to Brett Farve. So Peyton's the obvious choice right? Not so fast LiL Bro Eli isn't just chopped QB. It was a rocky start for Eli after being drafted in the 1st rd by San Diego he refused to play there and then the Giants and Chargers worked a swap for Phillip Rivers. All Eli's done since is win a Super Bowl in dramatic fashion against the mighty Patriots. He's evolved into a true leader, he plays with a quite confidence and he's cluth under pressure. He does what all great QB's do he plays big in the big games (Dallas Sunday night). He'll never put up the numbers that big Brother does because of the system he plays in but last time I checked both Manning's have a Super Bowl Ring. Either one you choose you can't go wrong. Peyton will be in the hall of fame and Eli right now is at the top of his game. There's only one way to settle this debate a Super Bowl XLIV Maning Brothers showdown and may the best MAN-NING win.