nickeydyme's Blog

NCAA got it wrong on Penn State

By nickeydyme | View all Posts
Posted Monday, July 23, 2012 11:58 AM   40 comments
The NCAA got it completely wrong in my opinion and I hope PSU appeals these sanctions. I guess the NCAA has to do something but holding a press conference to announce sanctions, they helped make this disaster bigger than life...these are criminal charges not sport infractions and Sandusky was tried and sentenced and I'm sure Spanier and Curley and whomever else will be too. Paterno is dead so I d...o agree with wiping the wins away and erasing him from campus because had he told the proper authority immediately he would have been in the clear.

But the rest makes no sense. No one is around anymore from this scandal in the football department so why ban these coaches and players 4 years of playing in a bowl and lost of scholarships? The 60 million in fines could have been done a different way, why not make all proceeds (tix sales, concessions, sponsors...) of football games go to the charity, this way you give the community a chance to come together and support the school/team/victims...Also, they kept saying this is "a bigger than football problem" then if they really wanted to cripple the school they should allow no new enrollee's for two years and see the results. Or if they had to do something to the football team why not no home games for two years, that would more than no bowl games and still be somewhat fair to the current coaches and players.

The NCAA just wants their name in the news, they should have sanctioned Arkansas football team for their coach cheating on his wife then. Or Virginia Tech for allowing a nutcase to go to school there that would one day shoot it up and kill innocent people. If this were to happen again no coach/athletic director/president would say we better tell the police because we don't want what happened to PSU to happen to us, NO, they would say we better tell the police BECAUSE that is what you do in this situation.

40 comments
comment Post A Comment
kimoinsd808 says:
07/23/12 12:05PM
PSU will still survive and thrive as an upper tier academic and research institution.  That's what it's there for isn't it?  Athletics should be secondary or even tertiary.
nickeydyme says:
07/23/12 12:06PM
I don't defend PSU at all, i'm a Spartan fan but it seems the punishment should have been to do away with the program for a year or two to really send a message.  These penalties really just affect the current players and coaches.  The school's name is ruined for a while. 
Capper007 says:
07/23/12 12:23PM

Nickeydimes take

The NCAA just wants their name in the news, they should have sanctioned Arkansas footbal team for their coach cheating on his wife then!!

They will still be on TV!!Scolarships and bowls (like the Meinke car care bowl) Are lost...IT WAS A COVER UP AND SCANDAL from every level  (janitor to head coach to President)

Your logic is flawed!

Penfold says:
07/23/12 12:31PM
It wasn't an NCAA matter no matter how much the sheep want it to be.  The NCAA stepped way out of line in this matter in order to appease the sheep.  
realscififan says:
07/23/12 12:39PM

 

Penn State got off the easiest possible.  They were not even close to get what they should have gotten.

They were criminally negligent for almost 20 years and this is all they get?

Penfold says:
07/23/12 12:44PM


Where do you get 20 years?  Completely false information.

1998 incident---fully investigated by the police, prosecution declined

2001 incident---Sandusky not found guilty on those charges

Freeh report---equivalent to a letter-to-the-editor opinion piece in a local newspaper.  Would never stand up in court in a million years.
realscififan says:
07/23/12 12:50PM

Wow, this ought to be fun. 

Mr Freeh has had over 500 documents in his career done by the FBI and private groups such as this admitted to the courts with ZERO..yes ZERO ever denied.  And many larger cases than this.

You are telling me that no kids...NONE...were abused by Sandusky?

Uh, Mr Sandusky was found GUILTY!!!!  Guilty even at a time when he was under the payroll of the University of Penn State. Evidence in the trials were found that Mr Paterno, and the Univ president and many others in the university was told about this and they did nothing. The minute they were told about this incident or any incident and did not tell the police, the FBI or the families of the children they were criminally negligent.

 

kimoinsd808 says:
07/23/12 12:52PM


Any punishment doled out by the NCAA was agreed upon by PSU if not outright asked for.  PSU asked and paid for the Freeh investigation and report and knew that the NCAA would be using it for the basis of their action. 

The NCAA action was taken independently and before any criminal or civil action has even taken place.  Sandusky was found guilty but he has not been sentenced.  The other two guys' trials haven't even started yet.  There have been no civil cases or settlements reported publicly.

You'll be hard pressed to find a PSU official speaking out against the action.  The only people who kick and scream against the action are people like you and in forums like this where the kicking and screaming will go away soon enough, fast and quiet-like.


kimoinsd808 says:
07/23/12 12:56PM


You should treat Penfold like you treat an upset baby, let it kick and scream and cry until it falls asleep. 
nickeydyme says:
07/23/12 01:09PM

i agree PSU got 1 year more bowl probation than USC for a far more serious crime then a violation of rules.  I was in favor for eliminating the football program for 2 years, the NCAA didn't need to make the rulings they wanted too.

nickeydyme says:
07/23/12 01:22PM
since this was an unprecedented situation i think they should have gotten more creative with their punishment, USC got 3 years no bowl and PSU gets 4 years no bowl? 60 million is a drop in the bucket to the power schools, and every program loses scholarships when they get in trouble...if this was such a serious thiing and it is, why not punish them in ways never seen before or thought possible...
Capper007 says:
07/23/12 01:57PM
So this wasnt a football issue? And why punish the current players and coaches..too late!! doing wrong and admitting it is 100% different than making a mistake and allowing it to continue...covering it up!! These nitnany idiots on ESPN are making me HATE penn state more (if thats possible?)
gold6185 says:
07/23/12 01:57PM
If people would take some time & READ The Freeh report- they would see that it CONTAINS the actual 2001  e-mails & notes  amongst  Spanier & Schultz & Paterno & Curley. that clearly show that these guys collaborated to whitewash & cover up the 2001 Sandusky shower incident for the sake of  The Penn State Football program. They attempted to cover up child rape. These guys have NO defense. Their owns e-mails & notes are out there for the world to see. It's  all there. Now come the civil suits & eventually Spanier & Schultz & Curley are going to wind up in jail.
Capper007 says:
07/23/12 02:06PM

The sentiment of Penn state fans

Gents, it has been a pleasure chatting with you over the last year or so, a lot of great people on here but I am done with college sports. Will not watch a game or support anything related to the NCAA again. What Emmert did today was beyond comprehension to me.

Does he think that a victim of this type of crime will ever come forward again knowing that if he does his entire community is going to be punnished when he does so? Will this punnishment scare univeristy administrators? It should (for any number of reasons), but I believe that it will also scare vicitms of similar crimes from coming forward in the future. Maybe I am wrong, but from dealing with many abuse survivors through my job, this would be their worst nightmare for many of them.

The NCAA had an opportunity here to really try and make a difference - hell turn PSU football into a non-pofit - put the bulk of the money from the football program into develping programs to support abuse victims, to educating the public that it is not only ok, but imperative that adults not look the other way, take the stigma away from asking the tough questions when something doesn't seem right, create a program that will develop counsellors for abuse victims and fund it through football. Do something that actually helps victims and helps prevent child abuse. Instead Emmert made a political power play for his own benefit in the name of these victims.

This could have been something that punnished the university and the football program as both would suffer without the funding, but that could actually do some good for victims of abuse and would not punish thousands of innocents in central PA or the student athletes at PSU.

While I think that the NCAA is misguided in punishing the football program, that pales in comparison to what I think they have done to the vicitms in this case and imo probably future cases that we will never hear about.

Cement your power Emmert, just don't look down at the people your stood on to get there, you might not like what you see.

Good luck to all of the PSU athletes, students and alumni that may read this, you deserve so much better than the leadership (or more specifically the lack thereof) that you have at PSU.

 

POOR LIL GUY!!! WAS THIS A SUICIDE NOTE??

Capper007 says:
07/23/12 02:07PM

THEN A GUY RESPONDED:

I'm almost at the same point you are.

I'm sure football will continue and I support the students/athletes are PSU, but I have a tough time figuring out how I can support them while showing my utter distain for our former and current administation.

Our former "leaders" sucked and our current "leaders" suck as well.

OFF NITNEY LIONS MESSAGE BOARD

jrivers says:
07/23/12 03:04PM
Yep you are right. The NCAA totally got this wrong.

They should've penalized them a lot more than they did. 40 years of hiding the truth and the fact that the victims will never ever be able to forget what happened to them. This story will never ever go away and for those that support Joe Pa and Penn St, bend over and let Jerry stick it in your a$$.

crazy1464 says:
07/23/12 03:50PM
FUCK PENN.ST  ALL WHO WENT TO THAT SCHOOL KNEW OR HEARD RUMORS ABOUT WHAT WAS GOING ON FOR YEARS! WAKE UP WORLD!
HutchEmAll says:
07/23/12 03:59PM
Not saying it prevents future infractions at future schools, but it makes it less likely that other administrations bury their heads in the sand.  

Does it prevent things from happening?  Nope.  But if I was an Admin. official at a school, I'd take notice and start putting strong checks and balances in place.  

This was as much a shout out to other schools as it was a penalty for PSU.  Right or wrong. 
Smith4722 says:
07/23/12 03:59PM
The ncaa got it right, honestly , i think they got a slap on the wrist
buckubad says:
07/23/12 04:02PM

$60 million is not a drop in the bucket to any school and its more like $108 million for starters.

nostradamus12 says:
07/23/12 04:07PM

The fine was equal to the average annual gross revenue of the football program. The money will be placed into an endowment for programs that work to prevent child sexual abuse and assist victims. No programs at Penn State can be financed by the money.

Actually the 60M in fines are going towards charity

Penfold says:
07/23/12 04:22PM

Well, I'm glad you had your fun.  Nowhere did I say that Sandusky didn't abuse anyone.  Also, where did I say that the administrators did nothing wrong?  You also fail to address the 20 years aspect.  Finally, I was pointing out the irony that the 1998 was fully investigated and Sandusky was acquitted of charges stemming from the 2001 incident.  So to punish a football program (that had nothing to do with any of this) and base that punishment on those 2 incidents is ludicrous.  I'm guessing due process is not something you cherish.  And apparently, reading comprehension isn't your strongest skill.
realscififan says:
07/23/12 04:46PM

Truth is not your main skill either.

Here is Joe Pa's statement:  "I was told about the incident in the shower and should have done more".   The minute he was told about the incident and he did not report it to the FBI, Police, and notify the parents of the child he became criminally negligent.  As a representative of the university that made the university as criminally negligent.

I do believe that Joe Pa was part of the football program.  So now we have Joe Pa negligent, the University is negligent and the football program is negligent.  There are not just 2 incidents, every incident that had any correlation to the incident that was told to Joe Pa now made Joe Pa as negligent for every incident afterward.

Example:

Lets say you are an accountant.  You work for ABC accounting.  You steal $100 million from one of your customers without knowledge of the company.

For that you AND your company are both at fault and are both responsible for the $100million.

Now lets say an intern tells you about this incident and you do a quick look at the books and find no wrong doing.  In the meantime you steal $100million for 10 others.  You, the company, everyone that looked at the original books and anyone that the company told is completely liable for those $100 million to each of the 10 clients.

Same here.  Once Joe Pa was told about the story and he did not go to the FBI, the police, and the parents of the children he became criminally negligable as well as everyone that was told and for every child Sandusky raped afterward.

That is the law.

Okay, not 20 years...only 14.  That makes it so much better!!!!

1969USC says:
07/23/12 05:05PM

Brillant.  A few people at Penn St. hurt some innocent people, so now the NCAA hands down a punishment that will hurt a lot of innocent people.

Remember when you were a kid, and your sister did something wrong, and your parents punished you too?  It was wrong then, and this is wrong now.

This is why I hate PC.  It is a cancer in our country.

HutchEmAll says:
07/23/12 05:06PM

It's as much about sending a message as it is punishing PSU.  Like it or not, it's just fact.  
realscififan says:
07/23/12 05:11PM

Wow is that off base.  The school is being punished because the school is criminally negligable. 

realscififan says:
07/23/12 05:15PM

And that is not "PC", that has been the law for over 100 years.  If you know of a criminal act and you do nothing about it, you are as guilty as the person doing the act. 

Had the representatives done anything except try to cover their asses they might have actually tried to help these kids and find out if it was true by contacting the FBI or police or even the kids families.

 

theclaw says:
07/23/12 08:46PM
Your comparing a coach cheating on his wife with a adult and a coach sexually abusing underage kids for years, wow, what is the world coming to.

There is not even the smallest remote comparisons to the two situations.

YieldSread says:
07/23/12 09:49PM
The cover up was wrong for sure. Does anyone really think that Joe Pa really thought he was covering for child molester, or was he not wanting to ruin a good friends career and reputation. Joe Pa did the minimum granted. How hard would any of you push to have your friend investigated for a sex crime when you were 100% sure he was innocent. I can't believe that Joe Pa or the higher ups actually believed that Sandusky was guilty of molesting children. Events have proved them wrong but I don't really think the thought they were covering anything up.
YieldSread says:
07/23/12 09:54PM
A man accused or investigated of a sex crime is quilty regardless of being convicted. This could be the reason why people who thought they knew Sandusky did not pursue it further. Turns out they 100% wrong but you can kind of understand to a small degree taking into consideration that he was investigated once and found innocent.
bikemcr says:
07/24/12 08:37AM
How does taking the wins away make sense ? The players on those teams probably did`nt know anything and the NCAA is saying "Ok you had an assistant coach who was a pedophile so you guys really did`nt win those games . Really ?
braves5795 says:
07/24/12 05:00PM
Joe Paterno thought he was above the law and the rest of the regular people. PSU got what they deserved, maybe evan a little less.
gmblr52 says:
07/24/12 06:01PM
It is absolutely disgusting and unconscionable to me that the senior powers at PSU not only did not stop the child rapist from raping more kids, but allowed him to use PSU facilities to groom and prep his next victim. If it was Jo Pa's son or grandson who McQueary said was getting raped in the football shower what do you think he would have done? I would bet Jo Pa would have gone into Sandusky' office and kicked his ass! Same goes for PSU's president. Is there anyone out there who thinks he would he have allowed the rapist to continue on his merry way if it was the President's own son getting sodomized in the PSU shower? Of course not, both of them would have been on the phone to the police in a heartbeat.

I hope the NCAA sanctions are only the beginning for PSU. I hope all people their who turned a blind eye to the rapist and allowed him to continue his disgusting behavior on campus are prosecuted, tried and jailed for their complicity in this tragedy. I hope civil lawsuits are filed and it breaks the bank at PSU. Only then might the victims begin to have some closure to what happened to them.

mattagent007 says:
07/25/12 01:01PM
Saying that PSU got hosed in the ruling is so wrong headed. First off Penn State agreed with the ruling so any comment on protesting it stupid. Gee they probably agreed to it because the FBI had a mountain of evidence and the dirt bag was convicted. Paterno his family and cult should be glad he died or else he more than likely been convicted of criminal negligence. The part I'm happiest about the ruling is the NCAA removing his wins. It seems to get people (including family and fans) the most emotional which means it's probably the best penalty. His concern about his record, his legacy and God complex is the reason this was covered up. Screw Penn State, their freak fans and student body ( who go there because the tradition of the football team).
The-Bulldog says:
07/25/12 04:45PM
Well, while I don't condone cheating on ones wife it's not illegal like butt blasting kids is. Couldn't disagree more with this article. I hope Penn St appeals this as well(if you did your homework before you wrote this you would know they gave those rights up). If an appeal were to be heard the possibility of up to 4 lost seasons was there. Good on the NCAA and may Joe Paterno burn in hell.
chopperocker says:
07/25/12 06:59PM
the current leadership at Penn State wanted the punishments so they could move forward with some amount of dignity. its only football and should have NO impact on anyone other than the players, team staff and theyre families. also the players and staff all have multiple other opportunities. remember the punishments were based on Penn States OWN internal investigation findings.
puritian says:
07/27/12 10:23AM
Penn St. football is no way responsible for what happen. This was a criminal act. The person who saw that act should have reported it to the police. Instead he reported it to the coach, who reported it to the head of Penn St. The Coach may have thought that nothing was wrong in that nothing was done. Its not the Coaches fault, as he is there to coach and not monitor police reports. If I saw someone committing a crime against another person I would step in and try to stop. If I saw someone stealing I might just tell the owner and not put myself out of my way. But crimes against people should be dealt with immediately, and not passed along to the next fellow.
purplecanoe says:
07/29/12 10:02AM
Jo Pa was treated like a king by everyone at Penn st. From the school president, all the way to the janitors. Nobody questioned his word, and his judgement was perceived to be of the highest moral ground. After all his team motto was Win with Honor. He had so much clout that speaking out against him was tatamount to treason. He pretty much had absolute power. And as the saying goes... Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

The penalties and fines levied against the school were more than appropriate. Of course innocent people far removed from the scandal are going to pay a price, but the penalty must be harsh enough to deter any future coaches or staff from committing such atrocious crimes, especially against children. Those that decide to do the wrong thing and break the law and/or cheat will ruin it big time for those that come after them. That is how it always has been with college sports, and that is how it always will be. I do agree that the monetary fines could have been directed to be paid to charities in the community...60 million could help alot of kids in and around the city.

I think Penn st wanted this to go away as fast as possible. They accepted the terms of the punishment without even thinking of an appeal. The last thing they want is to have this thing drag on for years in the court system, with a headline about new legal developments popping up every few months. They are eager to put this chapter behind them, and I don't blame them.

GoogsVL3 says:
07/29/12 11:49PM
Penn State deserves the "death penalty"! And I don't mean SMU style. Anyone with connections to the university that allowed children to be molested should be lined up and shot. Kill them!! Makes me sick that individuals witnessed this going on or knew about it and said nothing!! Shut down the university!!!
livie says:
07/30/12 08:11AM
Dumbass post. That's all needed to respond. Shut up forever dude
Add your response:
Please note that the blogger has the option of reviewing all comments before they are displayed to the public. Your comment may not be published immediately.
 

Profile

User: nickeydyme
Joined: June 2012
Location: Nevada
Team: Detroit Pistons
Occupation: Sales/Marketing

Recent Posts

Archive

Categories